Friday, February 27, 2009

And in the beggining there was....The Concept Board.

When you create a Concept Board you are ultimately creating a place to collaborate all your stimulus material, comprising of visual and/or text representations of your ideas based on a chosen concept that will inform you design. The Concept Board works simultaneously with the research you do based on your concept/brief. One is written expression and the other is visual inspiration and stimulation. Concept Boards are usually mounted on large boards so a group of people can easily see them. For Digital Fashion Communication you will be creating 3 Concept Boards that are A3 size. Concepts Boards can be quite polished like advertisements (movie posters etc), or they could be rough and look unfinished depending on what mood you would like to create as a response to your concept.


I showed you some examples of Concept Boards in class which are a representation of a highly creative concept board. Below are examples of Collage and Template based Concept Boards both created for an online store selling baby clothing and accessories. Notice how the visuals are laid out and constructed on the page.


Example 1: Collage


Example 2: Template


EXERCISE:

Which layout do you think best suits the concept and why? How would you make these boards better?

(Please use the comment function to express you thought about these two Concept Boards).


One website that I found that will help you immensely with your understanding of Concept Boards is:


I recommend that you all visit this site as part of your research for this class.

Have fun guy's!

Later L

23 comments:

  1. I'm rooting for the collage for this one. Though collages are MEANT to clearly convey the mood/theme and have that advantage of visuals against the template form...the collage fits the relaxed and I'm-your-friend themes going on ("handmade" especially and obviously!).

    Improvements wise, I MIGHT consider blurring edges of some of the pictures. This gives the "soft" feel that seems to be present only through the colours used. However, I quite like the hard edges as they mimic the cut+paste nature of scrapbooking...so it'll have to be trial+error here and there to see if it'd fit in the final design.

    I find the template does what it's supposed to do awesomely well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. the collage works better for the concept.... when i think of baby clothes and accessories i think of a homey feel, loving and etc... this is conveyed more within the collage as opposed to the template which seems very commercial... it doesnt have that touch which would makes you feel yer i want my baby in those clothes... the use of color also adds to this impact... creating a very natural warm inviting environment.... which works well with the soft child images...

    ReplyDelete
  3. The collage CLEARLY identifies what kind of products are invovled and who they are for (i.e. baby products). The handmade, crafty touches are typical of a baby scrapbook that a mother would keep. The large words: 'soft', 'sweet', 'baby' and 'handmade' really help in pointing out the mood of the concept board.
    While the colour scheme of both the collage and template are the same, I find that they are not unisex and seem to only represent masculine colours. Does this mean that the products included in the online store are only for baby boys?
    However, I agree with the other comments - the collage does convey the concept far better than the template.
    Having said that, since the final product is supposed to be an online store; the template is clear and uncluttered and appears to be easy to navigate, while the collage is not(but i suppose a collage is supposed to be that way). The template is quite simple and not particularly visually stimulating.
    Perhaps a combination of some features from the template and collage would create a better end product...

    ReplyDelete
  4. both of them are okay, but neither of them really work for me as a good concept board. concept boards are something you can look at and remind yourself of the design inspiration and motivate yourself. but both the collage and the template seem too plain and can't really trigger something, a creative idea for example. but in general, the colours are soft and cool, which work for this type of business, however i agree with jennifer, there should be more warm colours, perhaps red, or pink, or orange, to be able to appeal to both sexes (girls like pink stuff more than they like blue, right?).
    I guess there could be more patterns and soft edged designs dissolved in the background because these 2 just look too plain and boring... but this doesn't mean there should be lots of unnecessary designs everywhere. the overall themes used are good, so, a little more girly colours and patterns carefully dissolved in the back would give the extra touch it needs.
    P.S. this is just my opinion...

    by Bolor Amgalan

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am agreeing with all the above..

    The collage is without a doubt the best layout for the baby clothing and accessoried concept board.

    Because..i think the whole method of collage-ing (?), the overlapping of pictures, creates a gentle mood about it as this eliminates any structure on the template. The collage is also the better choice as it has a greater amount of colour and images which creates this playful mood- and this is what 'babies' are all about whilst on the otherhand, the templete is mainly white and is limited with visuals. On the subject of visuals.. because the collage has more visuals it better communicates the concept of the baby clothing and accesory range.

    Nevertheless i think i could be made better through the pictures of the collage having rounded edges, just to give it that extra bit of gentleness and also to keep a consistant amount of spacing between images, this will also give the collage a more gentle and well balanced look. Oh and one last thing.. I personally would scrap the brown from the colour scheme.. it's so not my ideal colour scheme for a baby range. I think it would be more appealing if they were to add more pastel colours.. it would increase the excitement factor.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The collage allows for the client to associate all things "baby", evoking on their emotions with the scrapbooking techniques and relevant pictures. It portrays the baby concept across in a more subtle manner, yet still highly effective.

    The template is a very get-to-the-point concept board, relying on straight factors(ie the sample colours, fabrics clearly spelt out) rather than presenting an array of baby associated images and text. It is quite clear, however ultimately I prefer the collage concept as it triggers more of a connection to the overall mood.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The First one, attracts the eye more and the message and concept is achieved to the viewer almost instantly
    Looks professional, yet interesting!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think that the template concept board looks cold and uninviting-too sterile for a website selling baby clothes and accessories. The collage concept board is much more visually appealing, appearing warm and comforting. the images and words on the collage concept board immediately cause the viewer to associate the it with babies-especially the duck, baby and spaceship. The soft colours further enhance the connection and the layout reminds me of a scrapbook-an item often used by mothers to keep pictorial records of their children.

    ReplyDelete
  9. oops, i forgot to write what improvements i would make. For the collage i would soften the angular lines by making them appear more organic. Otherwise i think its quite a good concept board.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i feel that the collage achieves the purpose more effectively. It is creates more of a mood through the use of colour and the large text and is more eye-catching than the template. The colour, images and text used are all very appropriate to the purpose of selling babies clothes and accessories. as others have said the template looks more sterile and does not evoke much emotion and doesn't feel like it would inspire people as much, although i guess it is more informative as it does contain more text, plus the baby pic is very cute!

    ReplyDelete
  11. The two concept boards have different objectives in which information they wish to relay to potential customers.
    The collage board is more inclined to portray a more personal message, as it is much more visually active than the template board. The idea of a more homely, scrap-booking and personal approach seems appropriate here, as the clientelle will generally be new parents who are after the best for their new born. This notion of the collage being more personal is highlighted by the text "our baby", which invloves the online store with the new family and instantly makes a connection with the potential customers.
    The template board however does appeal to me in that I prefer its colour palette to that of the collage board and also its layout is very relaxed and easy to follow, as it allows the viewer to easily take in the information presented. The template board is very formal and information oriented, which leads me to conclude that the collage is better for the concept... but thats not to say that the template board doesn't fulfil its objective in presenting the more finer details of the range.
    To improve the collage board, I would definitely think about rearranging the layout, as i think the focus should be on the picture of the baby and the text above it, then the eye can follow to board from that point around to the other pictures and words and back in.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It really depends on what you are using the concept board for. For example, if you were doing a presentation to another company, you would want to be able to communicate your ideas clearly and which in this case I would use the template. If I was doing a design presentation for class, then I would use the collage. In my opinion with the collage it is not really getting the point across about creating a free website. If I was to change this I would make the "Create your free wedding site" bigger and bolder, possibly in black so that it stands out more.
    With the template example, I would add less text and just dot points or key words are fine because when doing presentations, most people do not want to spend hours reading the small fine print on a concept board.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm not really a fan of either... the first is so kitsch; if you want to sell something, you have to grab the customer's attention. Personally, I don't think either will do so. The second is neat, clear and thus communicating the product well, but is no concept board; where's the life? the inspiration? I say redesign altogether, make something that's real and a little raw; I know it doesn't sound appealing, but parents know that babies aren't clean, neat pieces that sit on the mantle piece. Be realistic, show them something that empathises with them; it doesn't necessarily have to be uninviting. Suggestions would include; textures, designs and garments (soft things with hand prints) that reminisce of the embrace only a mother has for it's child; remind the customer of the REAL joy a baby holds so that they can actually relate to it. (people like things that understand them... don't they?)

    ... hope that made sense and wasn't just a ridiculous ramble.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The template is clean and crisp and in many ways resembles a webpage itself. It gives clear examples of each of the websites features but is rigid and less engaging then the collage.

    Both mood boards use shades of brown and blue to suggest that the clothing marketed by the store will be for baby boys. The collage however communicates this message further by adding other visual clues such as a robot (an image related closely to young boys). The collage creates an image similar to that of a scrap book. Many mothers are at some stage involved in scrap booking especially when it means preserving the memories of their child. For this reason the collage style mood board is more relevant to the type of customers that the online store is trying to target. The visual impact of the collage is very strong, giving a quick and clear overview of the visual style of the website. For these reason I think the collage is more effective then the template.

    ReplyDelete
  15. An examination of both mood boards reveals strengths and flaws in both designs. The collage has a much more effective visual impact through the use of the ‘scrap booking’ technique and hard lines. The eye is initially drawn to the bold headings “soft”, ”sweet”, “baby” and then “handmade”. The neutral and harmonious colour scheme is used to further emphasise these ideals.

    The simplistic layout of the template however makes it easier for the client to understand what is being presented to them. The sub-headings “Sample Colours” and “Sample Textures & Patterns” clearly relays to the client what the designer intends on using to create the webpage.

    In terms of which layout do I think best suits the concept I’m going to go with collage simply because it is fun and not to serious which is something we essentially associate babies with. Perhaps giving the layout a little more structure would enhance its effectiveness as a mood board.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think the collage best suits the concept. As the layout is directed towards a concept of babies and childeren it is much more visually interesting by utilising soft colours for all areas of space, with large rounded text and a variety of images relating to childeren.
    If I were to have input on the design of these boards i would probably suggest an softer layout and use more images, designs and ideas to convey a little more detail about the concept.

    ReplyDelete
  17. i like the collage best as i feel it is more expressive and thus can better communicate the mood and idea of the concept much better then the template. The template is clinical and boring to me and best suited for colour choice board. To improve the first mood board, i would suggest more brighter colours and images and free form composition to communicate the mood better. For example, i feel this is trying to communicate is a soft and serene mood but the composition is angular and somewhat austere.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I actually like the template better I think it gets the point across affectively. The collage is too cluttered for me. I like to see everything clearly and understand what they are trying to sell me. I also think the template is easier to navigate than the collage. Some of the suggestions I have is to have more bright colors and headings that attract attention and make you want to buy their product. They need to make their product seem more unique and desirable. Since the economy is so tough right now people are spending their money more wisely and want to get the best product for their money.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Although I initially liked the collage more on closer inspection I found that the template provided more information that would help keep the design to the brief.

    While the collage is able to immediately express the general mood of the piece, overall it is confusing. The pictures seem separated. The natural tones and then the leaves could suggest an overall natural theme. It then seems strange that you would include a robot which is completely artificial. Is it meant to be repeated as a pattern, a motif on a shirt, or a symbol that this is a collection aimed at boys.

    The template is quite mundane and boring. However, it clearly expresses the goals of the design without any confusion. I feel the text is too small to be effective in a presentation. Perhaps the template would benefit from having a background pattern or colour and a typeface which will help express the mood immediately.

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The collage is more aesthetic, however the template seems to have a more systematic logical approach. In this instance the first is probably better for its communication.
    Different colours more suited could have made both boards more appealing

    ReplyDelete
  22. OK so I actually think that the template is more successful in communicating the theme because it is easy to understand and the concept is obvious... however I also think that a concept board should be less structured in order to display the unordered process of thought. So therefore the collage achieves the aesthetic purpose and is better suited to the concept.

    The collage could be improved by blending the edges.... and adding more layers.

    ReplyDelete